On Sabbath morning when Jesus entered the congregation he was most likely invited to read to the congregation. He chose a passage of Scripture from the book of Isaiah and proceeded to read chapter 61, verses 1 and 2 which say “the Spirit of the Lord God is upon me, because the Lord has anointed Me to preach good tidings to the poor; He has sent me to heal the brokenhearted, to proclaim liberty to the captives, and the opening of the prison to those who are bound; to proclaim the acceptable year of the Lord, and the day of vengeance of our God; to comfort all who mourn”
The passage was a messianic prophecy, one that the entire congregation was familiar with and clung to with fond hope. They read it to mean that the Messiah would come upon them, breathing vengeance against their oppressors and would work miracles among them to set them free from the tyranny of Rome.
Jesus chose to shatter that false perception in one fell swoop when he calmly declared “Today this scripture is fulfilled in your hearing” While they hoped for physical liberation from a known and despised enemy, Jesus was proposing spiritual liberation from a far wilier foe. While they were hoping for temporal prosperity, Jesus was offering them spiritual wealth for their souls.
The silence that settled over the congregation was deafening. Not only had Jesus obliterated their fondest hopes but He had also pointed to Himself as the Messiah. At first, the congregation at the Nazareth Synagogue didn’t know which was worse; that Jesus was telling them that their dreams were nothing more than fanciful delusions or that all their hopes were, in fact, centered around him.
When they managed to find their voices to speak, the first word’s that came out of their mouths were “Who is this man? Is he not Joseph, the carpenter’s son?” Some of this whispering was about the lowly rank of his father but some of it was also casting aspersion on his mother. They had heard the whispers surrounding his birth; the claims of a virgin conceiving him. How could a man of suspect parentage possibly speak any sense? They spoke as though his parental lineage disqualified him from not only being the Messiah but also of speaking to them as he had done. For surely, they surmised, a carpenter’s son couldn’t possibly have the kind of spiritual insights that this man was pretending to have? A man whose birth was shadowed by scandal couldn’t possibly be posturing to be the messiah?